Saturday, 17 June 2017

Seriously polls, what's the deal?

Seriously, what the hell just happened?

For anyone not living in the UK, I'm talking about our recent election which took pretty much everyone by surprise. All the major newspapers and polls have spent the last few months proclaiming that Britain's right-wing Conservative party were due a landslide victory. This is more or less the only reason that Theresa May bothered to call an election in the first place- with polls reading two thirds of votes would go to the Conservatives, she figured that she could only gain by calling a snap election. Just to give you an idea of how wrong she was, and how wrong the polls got it, here's the headline from the Independent on election day:

'Final reckoning: May on track for sweeping win'1

and here's the headline from the same newspaper the day after:
'Black and blue: May's election gamble backfires'2

This isn't the first time polls have been vastly out either, with Donald Trump being predicted to lose confidently in the US 2016 election, and the Brexit referendum being viewed as a definite remain. So seriously, what happened? Quite a bit of money goes into polling the public about votes so you'd think the that this would get reliable results. YouGov for instance, one the the UK's largest polling companies, reported a turnover of £88,200,000 last year☀. You'd think when there's that much money at stake, companies would have found a way of making polls extremely accurate by now.

Maybe that's a bit naive though. After all, polling by its very nature is based on asking people questions, which is generally a bad idea. People are wildly wrong on most things, a recent survey by Ispos MORI showed that, as Britons, on average:
- We guess that the immigrant population is twice as large as it is.
- We think that there are almost 12 million less overweight and obese adults than there are
- We think that there are around twice as many non-religious people as there are.

So maybe we just suck at answering questions, and anything based on that methodology is always going to fail. But you'd think this wouldn't be such an issue with asking people there intentions or thoughts. As Evans writes, there's no real difference between asking someone if something is true, and if they think something is true֏. So if it's not down to us just being wrong generally, why does everyone keep getting it so wrong?

Part of it might be down to our overly complicated voting system- in the UK votes are dividing amongst more-or-less equally sized constituencies and then whichever party has the most constituencies wins the election. This leads to some pretty crazy rifts between votes and seats, and makes election results even harder to predict⅋. For instance Labour had 2% less votes this election, but ended up with 9% less seats4. So when even knowing the popular vote doesn't guarantee the election result, you can see why it gets difficult. Still, even at just predicting the popular vote, the polls were pretty far out.

Maybe the main reason that polls get it so wrong, is that they suck at predicting voter turnout. Evans Witt covers this in an NPR article: "We know polls do a poor job with emotion/enthusiasm/commitment"5. Getting people to stop in the street and answer questions can be hard, so polls tend to be short, and lack detail. People can tell you who they would vote for, but if you want to get an idea of exactly how likely they are to go out and vote for them, you're probably talking about a much more detailed survey that a lot of people don't have time for. This might go some way to explaining why two candidates who defied polls recently (Jeremy Corbyn and Donald Trump) were on fairly extreme sides of the political spectrum (Corbyn on the far left, and Trump on the far right). People with strong opinions are likely to be a lot more motivated to go out and vote than those who favour more middle-of-the-road candidates. It's hard to imagine people getting fired up at a Clinton rally in the same way as they do at a Trump one.

It's probably also true to say that polls are still pretty good even if they're not quite great. France's recent election in which centrist Macron comfortably defeated far-right Le Penn was universally predicted by polls. And many of the recent votes that have gone against expectations, like the US Presidential Election, UK General Election, and UK Referendum Vote, have all been extremely close calls. Trump won the election but not the popular vote. The Conservatives won the most seats, but not by enough to govern. The UK voted to leave Europe, but by a majority of 2%. It's easy to be down on polls, but all in all, they're fairly accurate, just not really accurate. Which, for predicting the future, is maybe not quite so bad. After all, weather predictions are notoriously inaccurate for more than a few days ahead6, and the weather is a much better understood phenomenon that the human psyche. Like Jung says, 'the great decisions of human life have as a rule far more to do with the instincts and other mysterious unconscious factors than with conscious will and well-meaning reasonableness'☮. Plus, it's not true that all the polls were wrong, there was one experimental poll by YouGov that managed to accurately predict the UK general election, but that was mainly ignored in the run-up to the election7.

So, do believe the hype, but just not very much. Wait, is that right?


1. The Independent, June 8 2017
2. The Independent, June 9 2017
☀. YouGov's financial investors report for the 2015/2016 year.
3. Ipsos Mori, Perils in Perception (2015)
֏. 'If someone asks me “Do you think there is going to be a third world war?”, I must attend, in answering him, to precisely the same outward phenomena as I would attend to if I were answering the question “Will there be a third world war?"'
G Evans, The Varieties of Reference (1982).
⅋. The US presidential election, also has a similar system. Which is why Donald Trump one, despite Hillary Clinton gaining more votes.
4. You can see the full breakdown of the vote share on BBC news.
5. Danielle Kurtzleben, 4 Possible Reasons The Polls Got It So Wrong This Year (2016)
6. Minitab, Weather Forecasts: Just How Reliable Are They?
☮. Jung, Modern Man in Search of a Soul (1933)
7. New Scientist, How YouGov's experimental poll correctly called the UK election (2016)

Monday, 29 May 2017

Fergusson's Dress

I was in Edinburgh recently, which is a city built on beautiful foundations: the crags of Arthur's Seat, the still country in The Meadows, the calm waters that make the Forth Estuary. There are beautiful buildings too, such as The Gallery of Modern Art1, which is filled in turn with beautiful things. There is Jenck's giant landform sculpture you are encouraged to walk across2; contemporary rooms featuring Coley and Hopkins; and masterpieces by Warhol, Hepworth and Miro. But There is this one detail, in one painting, that I keep coming back to.

The painting is called La Terrasse, Cafe d'Harcourt and it's painting by John Duncan Fergussonʤ. It's dated sometime between 1908 and 1909, which means that Fergusson was in his early thirties and living in Paris when he made the painting. Fergusson was by this stage well into, but still young in his career. You can see this in some of the details. The painting has one foot in the waters of post-Impressionism, the then popular style famously seen in Gaugin and Van Gogh3, but it's reaching out towards the avant-garde of its day- painters such as Matisse and the Fauvists👽. In a lot of ways it's a landmark of a painter still developing his style, looking backwards at the old masters, whilst stepping forwards into new spaces. This isn't to say that the painting lacks confidence: the figures are bold, are the colours assert themselves harshly. It's also worth mentioning at this point that it's an incredible painting, in every aspect.

The detail I keep coming back to falls in the 'new spaces' category, although there's plenty worth mentioning in Fergusson's inheritance of tradition. At the centre of the painting, a woman stands with a parasol, looking vaguely towards the viewer, her face is vacant and expressionless. Her dress is a pastel orange, and at the hem Fergusson has shaded the fabric with mauve-grey paint, and it's here that I keep drifting back to.

The key thing for me, is the way Fergusson has applied the shading- you can see this clearly when looking close. The brush has been ran up the hem of the dress, but rather than stop where the light falls, Fergusson just lets the brush run on, until it happens to run out of paint, in effect letting chance dictate where the light cut outs.

What really interests me about this, is that it's a moment where the painting becomes completely detached from its subject. Fergusson had no way of guaranteeing when the brush would run out of paint, or that it would accurately reflect the light of the scene. The detail is small, but it marks a point where the painting is not about anything but itself and its materials.

This is a feature which always stands out as one of the big divides between art which comes before, and after, the twentieth century. This was the century when art stopped being anything else, painters like Rothko, Pollock and Miro4 were no longer interested in making observations about appearances, but simply creating objects out of paint and canvas.

The twentieth century, with the rise of modernism, is the point where the subject becomes self reflective. It's this change in tide that has defined all future art, by making things possible that weren't before. Malevich's black square♫, Duchamp's 'Fountain' and other ready-mades☯, literature such the short stories of Cortazar5, which are always referring back to their own fiction, are only possible when interpreted as art object: not as representations of things, but as things in themselves, existing within a culture of others. It's this change in tide that defines the galleries, concerts and books of today, and if you look carefully at Fergusson's painting, amongst the hem of a dress, you can see the moment where the wave breaks.





1. Which, technically, is two beautiful buildings.

2. Jenck's calls it "a new language of landscape" (http://www.gardenvisit.com/gardens/scottish_national_gallery_of_modern_art)

ʤ. La Terrasse, Caf d'Harcourt, John Duncan Fergusson

3. A good overview of post-impressionism is here (The Art Story)

👽 . An overview (again from The Art Story) is here

4. For more similar works, see the Tate's article on Abstract Expressionism

♫. You can see the painting here

☯. See MoMa's Marcel Duchamp and the Readymade

5. Julio Cortázar, Blow Up (1967)

Tuesday, 18 April 2017

Ikea and Utopia

There is a surprisingly small number of Ikeas in the world; 3141. Yet, anyone who walks through an Ikea showroom will see tables, chairs and cupboards from the same living rooms shared by millions of people the world over. One article claims that the Ikea catalog is more widely distributed than the bible2. There is something universal about the furniture of Ikea. It is immediately both personable and faceless; stylish without character; and most importantly, affordable. There is a 'cut and paste' aesthetic to Ikea. Ikea furniture is designed to be unimposing, with sparse enough detail that it is immediately contextualised by it's surroundings. The stark functionalism, and lack of ornamentation means that a sofa from Ikea belongs at once to everyone and no-one.

The simple functionalism of Ikea is everyday now, so it's interesting to note the radical roots of the design style, which stems from Louis Sullivan's mantra that "form ever follows function"3. The functionalist style reached its foremost in the Stockholm exhibition of 1930. People came from all over to witness simple chairs, stark tables and practical upholstery. The style is often considered a default now, so it's easy to miss how it must have seemed at a time when style had previously been dictating by ornate craft, something only affordable to a few. Affordable design meant equality, and offered a way for harmony and elegance to enter the modern home. People passing by the displays must have felt that they were looking into a suddenly achievable utopia.

We can see the legacy of the design style by looking at two chairs. Firstly, one designed by the architect Gunnald Aspland and displayed at the Stockholm Exhibition (Fig 1), and secondly Ikea's 'Janinge' chair (Fig 2). Both are made from easily manufactured materials- Aspland's is designed from wood plates and metal, whilst the Ikea chair is completely plastic. Similarly, there are no structural elements to either chair that do not relate to function- no ornamentation is present, and the only non-rigid elements of either chair are slight contours which seek to mirror the users proportions. Finally, the only aesthetic design element☂ for either chair, comes from the use of colour which is bright, does not affect the use or structure of the object and importantly, is a cheap addition to the product☀.


"Enameled metal and lacquered wood chair"4


"Janinge"5


At the time, new technology was eager to guarantee a new era. New ideas such as socialism and communism promised the existence of a brighter future for workers with "nothing to lose but [their] chains"☭ and modern factories promised a route. But it's important to note the date. 1930. Marking the beginning of the great depression when capitalism would fail to provide steady employment for millions, and nine years before world war two where distorted technologies would forever clear the European association between technology and utopia. Within fifteen years, the promises of the Stockholm Exhibition would fold.

If the holocaust had not already brought an end to utopian thinking, then the atomic fear of the ensuing cold wars certainly achieved this. The era of utopias is unquestionably over, but it's true that many of the promises from the 1930s were met. Food is cheaper and more varied and home living is easier. Design has unquestionably become more of an element in everyday lives; Ikea and many similar companies delivering this. In many ways, we are now living in the utopian dreams of the 1930s. But when reached, it's clear that the dreamed world of the 1930s was never really a utopia. The furnishing have arrived (simplicity, economy, design) but the wider dreams (equality, freedom, happiness) have disintegrated.

Our world is free of utopias, although perhaps this isn't a bad thing. Maybe Utopia is best defined as, in the words of Albert Camus, "that which is contradiction with reality"∠. Search the pages of a modern catalog and you're more likely to find the promise to make lighting "easier and more affordable"6 than to melt all that is solid "into air"☭. Western culture no longer promises utopias, only a few small finishes for easy living. But maybe this, for now, and in the shadow of the 20th century, is enough.




1. This figure comes from Ikea's website

2. Tthe article doesn't provide citation: Telegraph, 25 Facts About Ikea (2012)

3. Louis Sullivan, The Tall Office Building Artistically Considered (1896)

☂. Or, to put it another way, the only design choices not dictated by function.

☀. Particularly when compared to ornamental design, which involves skilled craftmanship and therefore expensive labour.

4. Erik Gunnar Asplund; Enameled Metal and Lacquered Wood Chair for Restaurant Ellida at the Stockhold Exhibition (Source: https://www.pinterest.com/pin/42713896441864597/)

5. Janinge (Chair from Ikea Catalog) (Source: http://www.ikea.com/gb/en/products/chairs-stools-benches/cafe-bar-chairs/janinge-chair-yellow-art-60246080/)

☭. Karl Marx & Freidrich Engels, The Communist Manifesto (1848)

∠. Albert Camus, The Rebel (1951)

6. Taken from the Ikea website tagline for 'Smart lighting' on 17 April 2017.

Sunday, 22 January 2017

Two Different Ways of ∞

Since ancient Greek person, Anaximander, first came up with the idea and called it Apeiron1, ∞ has always been something of an ambiguous concept, one that escapes easy definition. It's definitely like, really, reeeaaally big and there's definitely more to it than that, but it's not always clear what that is. Almost everyone has a sense of ∞, but you could argue that it still lacks a strict definition. Throughout history, people have continually had different ideas of what ∞ is, and we can see this by looking at two famous arguments, both of which imply completely different interpretations of the concept.

One Way: ∞ as a Process (Aristotle's Refutation of Zeno's Paradox)

One way we can look at ∞ as as a sort of process. As if ∞ was a sort of way of saying 'just keep adding one continuously and don't stop'. This is exactly the view that Aristotle takes back in the third century BCE when he argues against Zeno's Paradox2. Bradley Dowden summarises the most famous form of Zeno's paradox as follows:

Achilles races to catch a slower runner—for example, a tortoise that is crawling in a line away from him. The tortoise has a head start, so if Achilles hopes to overtake it, he must run at least as far as the place where the tortoise presently is, but by the time he arrives there, it will have crawled to a new place, so then Achilles must run at least to this new place, but the tortoise meanwhile will have crawled on, and so forth. Achilles will never catch the tortoise, says Zeno. Therefore, good reasoning shows that fast runners never can catch slow ones. So much the worse for the claim that any kind of motion really occurs, Zeno says in defense of his mentor Parmenides who had argued that motion is an illusion.3

Effectively, Zeno is arguing that any distance Achilles moves, the tortoise will have also moved, and that Zeno has to move an infinite number of small distances. Therefore, the tortoise will move some distance infinite times. But, Aristotle responds, "while a thing in a finite time cannot come in contact with things quantitatively infinite, it can come in contact with things infinite in respect of divisibility"4. Effectively, to say a distance can be divided up into infinite parts, does not say anything particular about the distance itself, but simply goes to show that we can continuously divide it. It is not the distance therefore that is infinite, but our act of dividing which does not end.

In this way, Aristotle sees ∞ as a process. Saying something is infinitely divisible, it effectively saying something about what we can do to it, not about the thing itself. ∞ is a sort of process, one of endless division/addition.

Another Way: ∞ as a Number (Georg Cantor's Diagonal Proof)

The German mathematician Georg Cantor, viewed ∞ in a completely different way, more like an actual number than a process of endless division/addition. We can see this in his assertion that there are multiple different infinite numbers of different sizes. Despite sounding extremely complicated, the proof itself is actually beautifully simple. Cantor just shows that there are more numbers between 1 and 0 than there are whole numbers in total5.

To do this, first we need to imagine that we have all the whole numbers written down in order:

1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
There's more than seven numbers, but you get the idea. . .

Then, next to them, we write a decimal number for each one:

1. 0.00003430454657612443......
2. 0.10000000000000000000......
3. 0.32683268326832683268......
4. 0.35109845576243954373......
5. 0.45272885996767235436......
6. 0.33333333333333333333......
7. 0.31265585317839327284......

So now, for every whole number we have a number between one and zero. All Cantor needs to do next is show that we can find another number between 1 and 0 that we don't already have. To do this, we select the first digit from the first number, the second digit from the second number, etc:

1. 0.00003430454657612443......
2. 0.10000000000000000000......
3. 0.32683268326832683268......
4. 0.35109845576243954373......
5. 0.45272885996767235436......
6. 0.33333333333333333333......
7. 0.31265585317839327284......

Now to make a new number, let's just add one to each digit (if it's nine, we'll take it down to zero) and put them in order. So here we'd end up with 0.1171349....

We know this is a new number, because it's been changed from all the other numbers. For instance, it can't be the first number, because its first digit is different. Similarly, it can't be the second number, because the second digit is different. Therefore, we have a completely new number. But we can't put this number next to a whole number because for every whole number there is already a number between 1 and 0.

Cantor concluded that therefore there are more numbers between 1 and 0 than there are whole numbers, despite there being an infinite amount of both.

It's not completely clear what the implications are of saying there's more than one ∞, but it's definitely something that would be impossible if we treated ∞ as a process, like Aristotle, rather than as a number, like Cantor.

There's no great reason to think that either Cantor or Aristotle is more justified than the other in the way they consider ∞, nor is there any reason to think that they can't both be justified. ∞ doesn't seem to be strictly defined enough a concept for one of them to be right, and the other wrong. Perhaps the concept ∞ simply can't be strictly defined, and perhaps it is simply a practice, or a symbol, that can be used differently in multiple contexts, just as a toothpick and a cocktail stick can turn out to be the same piece of wood.

..............................

1. Wikipedia, Anaximander (2017)

2. Technically, Zeno's paradox is actually a series of multiple paradoxes, but since they're all more or less the same and only involve subtle variations on the same theme we can think of them as making up one paradox. Zeno effectively sat back on the success of one idea to generate multiple writing and in this way was the originator of the franchise sequel.

3. Bradley Dowden, Zeno's Paradoxes (2017)

4. Aristotle, Physics, Book 6 (C 350 BCE)

5. Georg Cantor, An Elementary Question of the Theory of Diversity (1891)6

6. Vihart has a great video on the topic (Vihart, Proof some infinities are bigger than other infinites, (2014))

Tuesday, 6 December 2016

Feedback loops and echo chambers.

If you take something which reacts to sound, say a microphone or a guitar, plug it into a speaker and then place it next to that speaker, something interesting happens. The instrument starts react to its own sound. This also means that the instrument reacts to this reaction (fig 1). It’s pretty easy to see how things escalate from there. Jimi Hendrix famously uses it to build up walls of guitar noise 1 ; what starts out at a single note spirals quickly in screeching catherine wheels and soaring planes. Since then people like Lou Reed 2 and Merzbow 3 have produced whole pieces of music consisting of nothing but feedback.

Fig 1.
Fig 1


Outside of sound, feedback loops remain an interesting concept. The logician Bertrand Russell, for instance, abandoned his project to provide a logical foundation for mathematics in part due to his inability to make sense of logical feedback loops 4 . Specifically, Russell was concerned with what is sometimes called The Liar’s Paradox which attempts to determine the truth of a particular sentence, namely:

“This sentence is false”

If the sentence is true, then we should accept what it states, namely that it is false. But if it is false, then we should disregard the sentence and therefore assume it’s true. The sentence is setup to respond to itself, just like the microphone by the speaker, so as a result its truth value seems to be in endless flux.

Feedback seems unavoidable too when we think about the way we interpret and make sense of the world. The phenomenologist Martin Heidegger wrote heavily about what he termed TheHermeneutic Circle5. He explained that in order to make any sense of something, we have to already have some kind of an idea of what that thing is. If we ask a question like “What’s the nature of being?” (which Heidegger did a lot), we have to have some kind of an idea of what ‘being’ is in the first place for the question to even make sense. “What’s the nature of being?” for instance, can lead to interesting conversations or thoughts, in a way that “What’s the nature of gleeb?” doesn’t.

So feedback can be important. It can make interesting sounds and textures. It can be difficult to understand but it is also always necessary for understanding. I think, particularly in light of many of the political events of 2016, that it can be dangerous as well. For the UK, in the morning after the vote to leave the European Union, and for the US, in the morning after Donald Trump’s presidential election, half of the country woke up not recognising their own country, and being frightened by what they saw. Meanwhile, the other half could not understanding why so many failed to share their excitement at a new wave of nationalist politics.

Events like this can seem a mystery, but when we consider the way are ideas and opinions are formed, perhaps we shouldn’t be surprised. It’s easy to develop views through talking to a small social circles, and journalism that caters to your views. It’s easier still to forget how our worlds can often resemble tight feedback loops, where opinions can spring from themselves. And again, it’s easy to express horror at the screeching catherine wheels of sound that other people’s opinions can seem to be, without taking notice of our own.

It’s not a realistic expectation to try and stop our own opinions from feeding back to us. Our worlds are always, to some extent, feedback loops feeding off themselves. But we can certainly try to broaden our horizons, to reign in our reference points, and to remember that other people inhabit different worlds. May your feedback loops be wide.



1. A good example of this is his performance of Wild Thing at Monterey in 1967 (which ended in him setting fire to his guitar) or his cover of Star Spangled Banner at Woodstock in 1969.

2. Lou Reed, Metal Machine Music (1975)

3. Merzbow, Pulse Demon (1996)

4. Andrew David Irvine & Harry Deutsch, Russell’s Paradox from Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (2016)

5. Heidegger talks about this throughout his career, it appears as a theme throughout his first work Being and Time (1927).

Friday, 28 October 2016

Nietzsche Hates Martinis

"Nowhere have the two great European narcotics, alcohol and Christianity, been abused more dissolutely."1

For something that's labeled a depressant, alcohol is pretty heavy with feel good vibes. For that reason, it gets a lot of popularity; in fact, according to a recent study, almost a third of us drink more than we should2. But who can blame us? Alcohol is the worlds favourite drug. As Bukowski famously said, there's always a reason to drink: If something bad happens you drink in an attempt to forget; if something good happens you drink in order to celebrate; and if nothing happens you drink to make something happen.3

You'd be forgiven for thinking that Friedrich Nietzsche would fit into this trend given his reputation as the anti-Buddha. In actual fact though, he hated gin even more than 18th century cartoonists4. Apparently Nietzsche would only drink water and, as an occasional treat, milk5. Milkshake was too far. Nietzsche almost certainly never drank milkshake.

The reason for this highlights a really central part of Nietzsche's writing, namely, the importance of suffering. Nietzsche felt that alcohol unreasonably dulled our emotions, and stopped us being dissatisfied when we ought to be. For Nietzsche, pleasure and pain were inseparable. In life, we should "live dangerously"6, open ourselves up to all experience that comes our way.

Nietzsche: What if pleasure and displeasure were so tied together that whoever wanted to have as much as possible of one must also have as much as possible of the other?7

It's definitely a valuable lesson. As a culture we tend to label specific emotions as negative (sorrow, anger, jealousy, etc), and then try to avoid or ignore them. There's a lot to be said for simply accepting these emotions, learning from them, and using them to better oneself, rather than vainly trying to avoid them.

Enough to stop drinking altogether though? Maybe not quite.

..............

1. Friederich Nietzsche, Twilight of the Idols (1889)

2. By "should", I mean in the opinion of doctors. In the eyes of bartenders it would probably end up being a smaller figure.

3. Charles Bukowski, Women (1978)

4. William Hogarth, Gin Street (1751)

5. The Philosopher's Mail, The Great Philosophers 4- Nietzsche (2015)

6. "the secret for harvesting from existence the greatest fruitfulness and the greatest enjoyment is: to live dangerously!" Friederich Nietzsche, The Gay Science (1882)

7. Friederich Nietzsche, The Gay Science (1882)

Sunday, 31 July 2016

Only Do Something If Everyone Could

(Kant's Categorical Imperative)

Being good can be a bit of a mine field sometimes; it's not always easy to know exactly what the 'right thing to do' is in any given situation, let alone actually doing it. For this reason, a whole lot of people during the enlightenment [1] spent their time trying to figure out a good way of telling what the right thing to do was in any given situation[2].

One of the biggest, and most influential examples of this was Immanuel Kant's Categorical Imperative[5] (Technically, to avoid upsetting Kant's dedicated fanbase, it's worth pointing out that this is the first 'formulation' of the Categorical Imperative rather than the whole thing itself). Kant suggested that in general, people should "act only according to that maxim whereby you can at the same time will that it should become a universal law without contradiction"[6]. In other words, you should only do something, if you think that everybody should be able to likewise.

For instance, lets say Billy really wants an mp3 of First World Problem[7]. Why not? The song is funky as hell. Problem: Billy doesn't have the spare cash to download the song. "No worries," thinks Billy, "I'll just illegally download the song for free; all of the funk, but none of the cost!". Trouble is, Kant's not having any of that because Billy can't sensibly maintain that everyone could act like that. If everyone was to pirate music, the bands wouldn't make enough money to keep recording music. So Billy's it's-ok-to-download-pirated-music principle fails, since if everybody adopted it then there wouldn't be any music to pirate. As a contrast, the principle of it's-ok-to-pay-for-music doesn't fall into these kinds of issues.

So far, so good. Kant seems to give a pretty easy to follow test for figuring out whether something is morally ok or not. It's also worth pointing out, as Onora O'Neill puts it, that Kant rules out "assuming anything specific about the agents' desires or their social relations"[8]. So Billy can't find a loop-hole by following the principle of it's-ok-to-download-pirated-music-if-your-name-is-Billy.

Ultimately though, the fact that your not allowed loop-holes is a bit of an issue for lots of people. Benjamin Constant was one of the earliest people to find trouble with this; suppose for example, he said, that a murderer turns up at your door and asks if your friend is in. Surely, you should say no, regardless of whether it is true or not? (Surely, Constant says, "noone has a right to a truth that harms others?"[9]) But Kant's a bit trapped here, since exceptions aren't allowed he's committed to saying that you shouldn't lie to the axe murderer since the principle of it-is-permissible-to-lie wouldn't work if everybody followed it. Kant responded to this criticism more or less immediately, maintaining that it really is always wrong to lie, even in a situation where you could save your friend from being murdered[10]. Maybe then, Kant's principle of 'only do something if everybody could' is a bit extreme for most people to follow. Even so, his insight into the connection between individual actions and societal rules has been hugely influential in the way people think about morality as a whole.


.................

1. Enlightenment. Noun. (/ɪnˈlʌɪt(ə)nm(ə)nt,ɛn-/) : After science made some big progress in the 17th century, a lot of philosophers got really excited and started writing a bunch about rationality until just before the 19th century.

2. This article's about Immanuel Kant's idea, but people had other suggestions as well. For instance Jeremy Bentham thought that the right thing to do was whatever made people happiest; having figured this out, he went to spending his time trying to figure out a good way of telling what would make people happiest in any given situation[3].


4. Alternatively, you can always speak to him yourself, since his body's preserved at UCL in London.

5. Yeah, sorry; it's got a big, long, pretentious name. Kant was into naming his ideas with complicated sounding terms like Transcendental Idealism or Synthetic A Priori.



8. Onora O'Neill, Kantian ethics. (1991)

9. Benjamin Constant, On Political Reactions. (1797)

10. Immanuel Kant, On a Supposed Right to Lie Owing to Philanthropic Concerns. (1797)