Thursday, 12 May 2016

It's Good to be Average

(The Golden Mean)

Often, people tend to think about morality as an all or nothing game. In situations, there's a right thing, and a wrong thing to do, and being morally good is about picking the right one no matter what. Aristotle, however, was a bit more easy going than this, and thought of morality more in terms of finding a balance. For him, being good was about being average.

Aristotle's suggestion wasn't that we should all try as hard as possible to be like everyone else [1], but that we should try to find the appropriate middle level of every characteristics. For instance, he points out that someone who "flies from and fears everything and does not stand his ground against anything becomes a coward" but on the other hand, going to "meet every danger" is being "rash". Courage therefore, is "destroyed by excess and defect" but "preserved by the mean" [2]. In other words, courage isn't about avoiding danger at all possible costs, or about running into danger all the time, but instead about finding the appropriate balance between the two. It wasn't just courage though, Aristotle thought that all virtues (honesty, charity, compassion etc) were a half way point between two extremes.

It's definitely a nice way of thinking about things, but as a way of understanding morality, it's not as popular now as it used to be. Probably because it's not very helpful for actually figuring out what's the best course of action in a dilemma, which people (well, academic types anyway) are pretty into now. Like, "If there's a whole load of people tied to a railway track and we can divert a train so it doesn't run them over but then it will run over another person, should we divert the train?" [3] Still, it may be more pretty than it is helpful, but it's always good to know Aristotle is out there, sticking up for the average folk.

........................

1. Especially since most people in Aristotle's time were slaves, and Aristotle hated slaves. He was more into the rich, powerful types like Alexander the Great who actually had Aristotle as his personal tutor.

2. Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics. Book 2, Part 2. (C340 BC)

3. Figuring out the answer to this question has been, like, the goal for modern ethics since Phillippa Foot first asked it in the 60s [4] [5].

4. Phillippa Foot, The Problem of Abortion and the Doctrine of Double Effect. (1967)

5. Seriously, people love this question- It even has it's own website and everything.